Every few months, someone tells me the office market is finished. I do not agree, and neither does Joe Brady. When I asked him on The Real Finds Podcast whether we are headed for more office distress, his answer was more precise than the headlines. The office asset class is not going to fail. The obsolete and irrelevant parts of it are.

That distinction matters to every owner, lender, and tenant in Chicagoland. Distress is not spreading evenly across office. It is concentrating in buildings that no longer give anyone a reason to show up.

Joe has watched this happen before. He led real estate for Walgreens, scaled The Instant Group across the Americas, and wrote Work Shop: The Consumer-Driven Transformation of Commercial Real Estate. His argument is that office is now living through the same reckoning retail went through over the past decade.

The Best Buildings Are Still Full

Joe started with the top of the market. He pointed to Jeff Blau of Related Companies describing Hudson Yards as fully leased. He then cited SL Green’s One Vanderbilt, next to Grand Central Terminal, which he described as 100% leased at roughly $275 per square foot.

His explanation was simple: there are amenities there, and people want to be there. The best office buildings in the country are not struggling for demand. They are competing for it and winning.

That is the first point I want owners to take away. When someone says “office is dead,” ask which office. The answer is never the building people are lining up to lease.

Sixty-Year-Old Buildings With Sixty-Year-Old Floor Plates

The problem sits at the other end of the stock. Using New York as his example, Joe said roughly 75% of the office inventory there was built before the IBM mainframe arrived in 1964. In his view, many of those buildings are now functionally obsolete.

Conversion is not an easy exit, either. Joe noted that many of those floor plates are far too deep to work as residential. An owner might find room for an urban brewery or a vertical farm, but in many cases the realistic answer is to scrape and rebuild. As Joe put it, owners of those buildings do not want to hear that.

I see the same tension in the suburbs. A building can be well located and still be the wrong building for today’s tenant. When the floor plate, the systems, and the amenities no longer match what occupiers need, a lower asking rent rarely fixes the problem on its own. The building has to be repositioned, or someone has to price in what it will cost to replace it.

Retail Already Showed Us How This Ends

Joe’s most useful frame is retail. He said more than 100 million square feet of retail has come out of the supply equation over the last ten years. Whole malls have been demolished and replaced with hotels and mixed-use developments. Former Sears and JCPenney anchor boxes have become multifamily, Life Time fitness clubs, and flexible office space.

He called it creative destruction, and he was clear that it has been going on for more than ten years and still has not settled. The retailers that survived did one thing well: they listened to their customers. In Joe’s words, consumers are telling us everything we want to hear. The question is whether we are listening.

Office is earlier in that cycle. The obsolete product will be removed, converted, or rebuilt, and the relevant product will take the demand that remains. That process will create distress, but it will also create opportunity for owners and buyers who understand which side of the line a building sits on.

Ribbon Cutting Is Only the Beginning

Joe did not spare the office industry. He described it as having become complacent, with an attitude that once the ribbon was cut, the job was done. He argues the opposite. The ribbon cutting is only the beginning, because the building has to keep earning its occupants every day.

His reasoning is that employees are the new consumers, whether owners and corporate occupiers realize it or not. Office space has to be thought of as experiential and closer to hospitality than the old cubicle farm, where showing up at an assigned desk under a manager’s eye was treated as productivity. Joe called that assumption a tremendous fallacy.

For landlords, this is a management question as much as a design question. Tenant experience, building services, responsiveness, and the quality of common areas are no longer extras. They are the product.

The New Collar Economy and the Tuesday Through Thursday Curve

Joe describes today’s workforce as part of a “new collar” economy. Technology has untethered knowledge workers from the industrial-era model of going to a factory nine to five, Monday through Friday, which is what the modern office became.

He was careful not to overstate it. Some jobs and some professions do require being in the office every day. For much of the knowledge economy, though, workers are voting with their feet. Joe sees Mondays and Fridays running very low, with attendance concentrated on Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday.

That matches what I see in our own transactions. In the office leases our team has completed recently, most occupiers are planning around three and a half to four days per week in the office. That is not the death of office. It is a different occupancy pattern, and it changes how much space a company needs and what that space has to deliver.

Purposeful Presence Over Passive Attendance

Joe’s answer is that leadership has to orchestrate what he calls purposeful presence rather than passive attendance. People need a reason to come in, and that reason has to be worth the trip.

He shared research from his previous role on commuters who live in Westchester County and work in Midtown Manhattan. According to Joe, that commute cost the average person about $8,000 per year after tax in transportation and food. More importantly, it cost at least two hours a day, or ten hours a week, that could have gone to family, sleep, exercise, or anything else.

He brought the point home to Chicago. If an employee in the western suburbs is going to get on Metra and ride into the Loop, there had better be a good trade and a clear purpose for doing it. Since the pandemic eased, people are making that calculation every week.

What This Means for Office Owners in the Chicago Suburbs

So, are we headed for more office distress? I believe we are, but not across the board. It will concentrate in buildings that are obsolete, poorly managed, or unable to give tenants a reason to be there. Well-located, well-run buildings that treat tenants like customers are in a very different position.

If you own suburban office, the questions to ask now are practical. Does your floor plate still work for the tenants in your market? Are your amenities and services competitive with the building down the street? Is your management team treating tenant experience as part of the product? If the honest answers are no, it is better to plan the repositioning, the conversion study, or the sale now than to wait for the lender to force the decision.

For current market conditions, see the daily-updated RFP Chicagoland Commercial Real Estate Index. If you have vacant space that needs a plan, our guide on leasing a vacant commercial building faster is a good place to start, and our brokerage, management, and development team can help you decide which side of the line your building sits on. Catch my full conversation with Joe on The Real Finds Podcast.


Van Vlissingen and Co. has been the Midwest’s oldest commercial real estate brokerage, development, and management firm since 1879, and today is independently ranked the #1 commercial real estate agency in Chicagoland, home to the #1 independently ranked agent, Gordon Lamphere, and the region’s #1 ranked commercial property management team. If you own, lease, or invest in office property across Lake County, the North Shore, the Northwest and O’Hare corridors, DuPage and the I-88 corridor, Will County, or southern Wisconsin’s Pleasant Prairie, Kenosha, and Racine markets, contact Van Vlissingen and Co. at 📞 847-634-2300 or 🌐 vvco.com. For a market-wide view of where these dynamics sit today, see our State of the Chicagoland Commercial Real Estate Market for Q3 2026.

We're Here To Help

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
I'd Like To...
Name(Required)
OP IN