Ten years ago, I would not have used the words “mall” and “value” in the same sentence. The consensus in commercial real estate was settled. E-commerce would empty the department stores, the anchors would go dark, and the enclosed mall would become a cautionary tale for anyone who owned retail. Today I am watching mall and strip center redevelopments work across Chicagoland, and I think the asset class is still priced as if that old consensus were true.
I tested that view with Elizabeth LaFontaine, Director of Research at Placer.ai, when she joined me on The Real Finds Podcast. Before Placer.ai, she spent more than a decade in retail and consumer insights at Macy’s, Stein Mart, and Circana. Her answer was that the mall has not disappeared. It has changed what it is for, and the owners who understand that change are the ones being rewarded.
The Consensus Was Wrong
Elizabeth was candid about it. Early in her career, she never expected to spend her time focused on brick and mortar, because the industry broadly assumed physical stores had no meaningful future once e-commerce took hold. E-commerce did disrupt retail for a long time. But she said it has been great to be proven wrong over the last decade.
That reversal matters for investors because pricing tends to lag sentiment. When an asset class is written off, capital leaves, values fall, and the properties that survive often trade at a discount to what they will earn once the market catches up. I believe parts of the mall sector are still in that gap.
The Mall as a Barometer
Elizabeth described malls as one of the best barometers available for discretionary spending. Grocery trips happen regardless of the economy. A trip to the mall is a choice. When shoppers feel confident, mall visits rise. When they feel squeezed, the mall is one of the first places they cut back.
For investors, that cuts both ways. Malls are more sensitive to consumer sentiment than a grocery-anchored center, which is a real risk. They are also one of the clearest places to see a recovery take hold, which is why I watch mall traffic as closely as any other indicator in retail.
The Original Third Place
The most interesting part of our conversation was about why people go to the mall at all. For older generations, Elizabeth said, the mall was the cornerstone of the third place: somewhere outside of home and office to gather, spend time with family and friends, browse, and be social.
That role faded as shopping moved online. Now it is returning. Elizabeth said Gen Z is bringing the mall back as a social destination, and she believes it is happening in a meaningful way, which has benefited the format overall. A generation that grew up on screens is choosing to spend time in a physical place with other people. That is a durable source of demand, not a short-term bounce.
Bringing the Mall Into the 21st Century
Elizabeth was also clear that demand alone does not save a mall. Owners and operators have faced a hard question: how do you make the mall relevant to a shopper who discovers products on a phone and often decides what to buy before arriving?
Her answer is tenant mix. It is not about adding more stores, or more stores in one category. It is about the right retailers blended together to tell a coherent story to the consumer and meet that consumer’s needs. On top of that, the strongest owners are adding experiential elements, restaurants, and more dining to create a complete visit that shoppers did not have at the mall of twenty years ago.
She added an important qualifier when we discussed what is overrated in retail. Experience, as it was pitched before the pandemic with technology and spectacle, is overrated in her view. Experience now means good service and a visitor who leaves satisfied and feeling they got value. That is a lower-cost, more practical standard for a mall owner to meet.
Not All Malls Are the Same
Treating “malls” as one asset class is a mistake, and Elizabeth’s data shows why. Each year a different mall format has led growth:
- Indoor malls led in 2025, after a heavy cycle of reinvestment and tenant changes in 2024 and 2025.
- Open-air lifestyle centers are growing fastest in 2026, as they reset their own tenant mix, bring in brands shoppers want, and add dining. They also work as community hubs, close to where people live, combining weekly errands with weekend browsing.
- Outlet centers are the surprise laggard. They should be built for a value-hungry consumer, but off-price chains such as T.J. Maxx, Ross, and Burlington are winning that trip instead.
The lesson is that format, location, and tenant strategy matter more than the label. A repositioned indoor mall with a strong mix and an outlet center losing to off-price are entirely different investments.
Why the Suburbs Help
Placer.ai’s migration data also supports suburban retail more broadly. Elizabeth described a suburban renaissance that began in 2020 and has strengthened as millennials and older Gen Z move into family formation. Those households want the brands and experiences they had in the city, closer to home, and some metro-based brands are following them to the suburbs. Well-located suburban malls and lifestyle centers are positioned to capture that demand.
Why I Think the Asset Class Is Underrated
Here is my view, as a broker who sees retail deals across the northern and northwest suburbs. Malls are underrated for three reasons. First, the market still prices many of them for decline, even though visit data shows renewed demand. Second, the value is in the repositioning. Owners who can change the tenant mix, add dining, and in some cases introduce other uses can create value that a static buyer will miss. Third, the demand drivers Elizabeth described, the third place, Gen Z, and the suburban shift, are long-term, not cyclical.
The risk is real too. Malls are sensitive to discretionary spending, large anchor boxes are expensive to backfill, and a repositioning takes capital and patience. This is not an asset class to buy on a headline. It is one to underwrite carefully, center by center.
What Owners and Investors Should Do
For owners, lenders, and investors across Lake County, Illinois, the North Shore, and Southern Wisconsin, the practical takeaway is simple: the box is not the asset, the tenant mix is. Study visit trends against competing centers, look hard at what the anchors are doing, and measure every leasing decision against whether it makes the center a better place to spend time. For current Chicagoland market conditions, see the daily-updated RFP Chicagoland Commercial Real Estate Index, and talk with our brokerage, management, and development team about repositioning or acquiring retail. Catch the full conversation with Elizabeth on The Real Finds Podcast.
Van Vlissingen and Co. has been the Midwest’s oldest commercial real estate brokerage, development, and management firm since 1879, and today is independently ranked the #1 commercial real estate agency in Chicagoland, home to the #1 independently ranked agent, Gordon Lamphere, and the region’s #1 ranked commercial property management team. If you own, lease, or invest in retail, shopping center, or mixed-use property across Lake County, the North Shore, the Northwest and O’Hare corridors, DuPage and the I-88 corridor, Will County, or southern Wisconsin’s Pleasant Prairie, Kenosha, and Racine markets, contact Van Vlissingen and Co. at 📞 847-634-2300 or 🌐 vvco.com. For a market-wide view of where these dynamics sit today, see our State of the Chicagoland Commercial Real Estate Market for Q3 2026.