Before the pandemic, almost every retail pitch I saw promised the same thing. The store of the future would be an experience. There would be interactive displays, digital mirrors, app-driven checkout, and spaces designed for photographs as much as for shopping. Landlords were told that experience was the answer to e-commerce, and many of them spent heavily to deliver it.
I asked Elizabeth LaFontaine, Director of Research at Placer.ai, what she thinks is overrated in retail today when she joined me on The Real Finds Podcast. Her answer was experiential retail, at least as the industry defined it six or seven years ago. Before Placer.ai, she spent more than a decade in retail and consumer insights at Macy’s, Stein Mart, and Circana, and she started her career on the sales floor. Her view of what shoppers actually want is grounded in both the data and the store.
Three Levers: Value, Convenience, and Experience
Elizabeth frames the question around three levers retailers can pull to build awareness and a relationship with shoppers: value, convenience, and experience. Every successful retailer leans on at least one of them, and the strongest lean on more than one.
Going into the pandemic, she said, the industry was focused almost entirely on the third lever. The questions were how to make stores more experiential, how to make them cutting edge, and how to make them technology forward. Value and convenience were treated as less exciting, even though they were often what brought shoppers through the door.
What Experience Actually Means
Elizabeth was careful to say that experience still matters. She called it incredibly important in brick and mortar. What has changed is the definition.
In her view, experience is not about bells and whistles or the latest technological advancement. It is about good customer service. Does the customer have a good experience when they come in the door? Do they leave the store feeling satisfied? Do they feel they got the most value out of the visit and the purchase? Experience, as the industry thought about it before the pandemic, is overrated. Giving the customer a good experience is where retail has to focus over the next five to ten years.
A View From the Sales Floor
Elizabeth’s perspective makes more sense when you know where she started. Her first retail job was in a store, working at the American Girl store in New York City, before she moved into merchandising and then into data and insights. She told me that working with shoppers in person, and watching how they move through a store, teaches you what is going on in a customer’s mind at the moment they decide to buy. It also shows you the joy that a good retail visit can bring.
That is a different starting point from a design brief or a technology demo. It explains why her definition of experience centers on the customer’s feeling at the door and at the register, not on the features of the space.
I think her correction is a healthy one. Shoppers rarely return to a store because of a screen on the wall. They return because the store was easy to shop, the staff were helpful, the product was there, and the price felt fair.
Value and Convenience Never Went Out of Style
The rest of our conversation shows why the other two levers deserve more attention. The fastest growth Elizabeth sees is in value channels: off-price chains such as T.J. Maxx, Marshalls, Ross, and Burlington, plus dollar and discount stores. These stores are not built around technology. They are built around price and a treasure hunt that gives shoppers a reason to come back every week. In a sense, that treasure hunt is the experience, and it costs very little to deliver.
Convenience has also returned. Elizabeth noted that the retail industry walked away from convenience early in the pandemic and has had to come back to it as more people commute again. Retailers are choosing smaller, grab-and-go formats instead of default big boxes, and they are placing stores where shoppers already are. That is a convenience strategy, not an experiential one.
Where Experience Still Earns Its Place
None of this means experience has no role. Elizabeth pointed to malls, where owners have succeeded by recalibrating tenant mix and adding experiential elements, restaurants, and more dining to create a complete visit. The difference is that the experience comes from the mix of tenants and the reason to spend time there, not from expensive technology inside a single store.
She also sees experience in categories built around gathering. Bookstores, which were the first category disrupted by e-commerce, are seeing physical traffic grow again because the visit itself has value. Small indulgences such as crafting and games like mahjong are drawing shoppers who want to celebrate small wins and spend time with friends. Those are experiences, but they are simple, social, and affordable.
Her underrated pick fits the same pattern. A second wave of digitally native brands is beginning to open physical stores, using brick and mortar to build awareness and cement their relationship with shoppers. The store is there to serve the customer and the brand, not to show off.
What This Means for Landlords and Investors
From the leasing side, I see three practical lessons. First, underwrite the operator, not the concept. A tenant with an exciting story and weak execution is a riskier credit than a well-run value or convenience tenant. Second, be cautious about funding highly customized experiential build-outs. In my experience, space built around a single concept can be expensive to re-lease if that concept does not last. Third, think about experience at the center level. The best shopping centers create a reason to visit through tenant mix, dining, and service, and every tenant benefits from that.
For a retail center in Lake County, Illinois or anywhere across the Chicago suburbs, that usually means a strong grocery or value anchor, convenience-oriented tenants that bring frequent trips, and a handful of service, dining, and gathering concepts that make shoppers want to stay. That combination covers all three levers without betting the property on one idea.
The Bottom Line
Experiential retail is not dead, but the version that dominated retail pitches before 2020 is overrated. Shoppers want value, convenience, and a store that treats them well. Owners and lenders who underwrite for those things, rather than for the most impressive concept in the room, will own centers that hold up over the next decade. For current Chicagoland market conditions, see the daily-updated RFP Chicagoland Commercial Real Estate Index, and talk with our brokerage, management, and development team about the right tenant mix for your property. Catch the full conversation with Elizabeth on The Real Finds Podcast.
Van Vlissingen and Co. has been the Midwest’s oldest commercial real estate brokerage, development, and management firm since 1879, and today is independently ranked the #1 commercial real estate agency in Chicagoland, home to the #1 independently ranked agent, Gordon Lamphere, and the region’s #1 ranked commercial property management team. If you own, lease, or invest in retail, shopping center, or mixed-use property across Lake County, the North Shore, the Northwest and O’Hare corridors, DuPage and the I-88 corridor, Will County, or southern Wisconsin’s Pleasant Prairie, Kenosha, and Racine markets, contact Van Vlissingen and Co. at 📞 847-634-2300 or 🌐 vvco.com. For a market-wide view of where these dynamics sit today, see our State of the Chicagoland Commercial Real Estate Market for Q3 2026.